
Why Freddy’s Custard Is Different
Freddy’s doesn’t serve soft-serve. It serves frozen custard — churned fresh in small batches throughout the day with egg yolks for extra richness. The result is denser, creamier, and thicker than regular ice cream, which is why Freddy’s concretes and shakes hold their texture instead of going watery. If you’ve only had the steakburgers, you’re missing half the menu.
This guide walks through every frozen custard item on the Freddy’s menu — concretes, frosts, shakes, floats, sandwiches, and take-home pints — with honest tasting notes and a ranking from best to worst. Prices and calories are typical 2026 values; check the full Freddy’s menu for the complete chart.
Freddy’s Concretes, Ranked
Concretes are Freddy’s signature: vanilla or chocolate custard blended thick with mix-ins, served upside-down-able. Here’s every one, ranked:
1. Signature Turtle — The Classic
$6.49 | 730 Cal. Hot fudge, caramel, and pecans in vanilla custard. This is the concrete that built Freddy’s reputation, and it earns it — the sweet-salty-nutty balance is perfect. If you try one concrete, make it this one.
2. OREO Double Trouble — The Crowd-Pleaser
$6.49 | 540 Cal. Double the OREO cookie pieces blended into vanilla custard. Simple, but the cookie-to-custard ratio is spot-on and it’s one of the lighter concretes calorie-wise.
3. Cold Brew Caramel Crunch — The Modern Favorite
$6.49 | 790 Cal. Cold brew coffee, caramel, and crunch pieces. Tastes like a fancy coffee-shop dessert in frozen form. At 790 calories it’s a commitment, but coffee lovers won’t regret it.
4. Peanut Butter Bonanza — The Rich One
$6.49 | 530 Cal. Peanut butter and fudge in vanilla custard. Dense and deeply peanut-buttery. A must for PB fans; too heavy if you’re not.
5. Reese’s Royale — The Candy Bar
$6.49 | 700 Cal. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups blended in. If you love the cups, you’ll love this — though the Bonanza is the purer peanut butter experience.
6. Chocolate Brownie Delight — The Fudge Bomb
$6.49 | 700 Cal. Brownie pieces and fudge in chocolate custard. Maximum chocolate. Best shared unless you’re truly committed.
7. Strawberry Dreamcake — The Fruity One
$6.49 | 690 Cal. Strawberries and cheesecake pieces. The only fruit-forward concrete, and a nice break from the chocolate-peanut butter lineup.
8. Dirt ‘n Worms — The Fun One
$6.49 | 530 Cal. OREO crumbs and gummy worms. Ordered for the nostalgia, enjoyed for the crunch. Kids love it; adults order it ironically, then finish it unironically.
9. Maple Pecan Concrete — The Underrated
$6.49 | 770 Cal. Maple and pecans — warm, autumnal flavors. Excellent but overshadowed by the Turtle; try it in the fall.
10. Create Your Own — The Wild Card
$5.99 | 330 Cal (base). Pick your custard and mix-ins. The ceiling here is higher than any signature concrete — ask what’s in the topping station (marshmallow, butterscotch, cheesecake pieces) and build your masterpiece.
Frosts, Shakes & Floats
Lemon Cream Frost & Orange Cream Frost — The Refreshers
$5.99 | 450 / 540 Cal. Freddy’s take on the creamsicle: citrus blended with custard. The Lemon Cream is the standout — bright, tangy, and lighter-tasting than any concrete. Perfect summer order.
Shakes — The Thick Ones
$5.49 | 560 Cal. Because it’s custard, not ice cream, Freddy’s shakes are genuinely thick — straw-standing-up thick. Chocolate and vanilla are classics; ask about seasonal flavors.
MUG Root Beer Float — The Nostalgia Play
$4.99 | 440 Cal. Vanilla custard dropped into MUG root beer. The custard melts slower than ice cream, so the float stays creamy to the last sip.
Custard Sandwiches & Take-Home
Chocolate Chip & OREO Custard Sandwiches
$2.99 | 300 / 310 Cal. Custard pressed between two cookies. The OREO version is the better of the two — the cookie crunch holds up against the cold custard.
Dish (No Toppings) & Pints/Quarts
$4.49 / $7.99. Sometimes you just want the custard itself. The plain dish lets the fresh-churned flavor shine, and pints ($7.99) are the move for home — the custard refreezes well for a day or two.
How to Order Like a Regular
- Size strategy: Concretes are rich — a regular satisfies most people. Minis exist for some sundaes; ask.
- Mix custards: You can usually get a half-vanilla, half-chocolate base in any concrete. The Turtle in chocolate custard is elite.
- Warm toppings matter: Hot fudge and warm caramel on cold custard is the whole point. Don’t skip them.
- Check for limited-time flavors: Freddy’s rotates seasonal concretes and frosts. The menu PDF lists the core lineup; ask in-store what’s new.
The Bottom Line
Start with the Signature Turtle, graduate to the Cold Brew Caramel Crunch, and cool off with a Lemon Cream Frost in summer. And when you’re ready to go off-menu, the Create Your Own concrete is your canvas.
Find your nearest Freddy’s and taste-test the ranking yourself.
Freddy’s Custard FAQs
Is Freddy’s custard gluten-free?
The plain vanilla and chocolate custard are typically gluten-free, but concretes with cookies, brownies, and candy are not. Always check with your location about ingredients and cross-contact.
What’s the lowest-calorie custard treat?
A plain Dish with no toppings ($4.49 | 330 Cal) or the Create Your Own base. Among signatures, the OREO Double Trouble (540 Cal) and Dirt ‘n Worms (530 Cal) are the lightest.
Can I get a dairy-free option?
Freddy’s custard is dairy-based and there is currently no dairy-free frozen dessert on the standard menu. Lemonades and teas from the Bevies lineup are dairy-free alternatives.
Do concretes really get served upside down?
The thickness is real — a properly blended Freddy’s concrete is dense enough to hold. (Whether your crew demonstrates it is another matter.)


